Our Blog

The Twelve Days of Tort Law: Premise Liability

On the first day of Christmas, my in-laws served on me! A complaint alleging premise liability!

Welcome to the first installment of The Law Office of Christopher J. Mutchler’s festive twelve part satirical series on Connecticut personal injury law: premise liability. Let’s get to the question you’re all asking:

What is premise liability, and how can it ruin my holiday?

In Connecticut, people are obligated to make sure their guests aren’t injured on their property. Depending on who’s on your property and why, that duty is different. But because you probably won’t be having your plumber over on Christmas Day to fix the pipe that’s been leaking all month, we’ll focus here on social guests.

Social guests are people you invite over for fun. Your cousins, aunts, uncles, parents, friends and coworkers who are there for dinner of Christmas eve are all social guests. The law calls these people “licensees.” In Connecticut, you owe these people several duties, including the following*:

(1) a duty not to intentionally harm them or set a trap for them;

(2) a duty to exercise due care with regard to him/her;

(3) a duty to warn of hidden dangerous conditions known to you; and

(4) a duty to warn of any dangerous activities that you are engaged in.

In English, you say? Let me give it a shot.

Connecticut law requires first that you not do anything on purpose to harm your guests, and prohibits you from setting traps for them. Now, this doesn’t mean you can sue your Great Aunt Judy for roping you and you’re fiancé into an uncomfortable conversation about living in sin. Injury law is concerned with physical injuries. However, if your Great Aunt Judy invited you upstairs under the guise of meeting her favorite cat, Mittens, but instead lured you to fall through a fake step, you might have a cause of action for premise liability.

Connecticut law also requires you to exercise “due care” with regard to your guests. While what precisely due care is in any given situation is a topic of great scholastic debate, suffice it to say you’re probably on the hook for damages if you for some reason decide mop your floor after the seventh round of drinks and send Uncle Jim to “hurry and get the eighth” without warning him.

You must also warn of any dangerous conditions you know about, like the shaky railing going down into the basement, and must let your guests know if you are doing something dangerous when they arrive (like playing with fireworks).

So that about sums it up! Obviously, this list is, of course, non-exhaustive, and is by no means a suitable substitute for the advice of competent legal counsel with respect to any particular issue concerning your own liability or the liability of others.

I hope you enjoyed installment one of The Law Office of Christopher J. Mutchler’s festive twelve part series on Connecticut personal injury law! You can find the rest of the series by following the link below:

Life’s not always fair, but it may be fairer than you think it is. If you’re in a bind, the Law Office of Christopher J. Mutchler may be able to help!

The Twelve Days of Tort Law: A Festive Compendium of Connecticut Personal Injury Law

In the spirit of the holidays, I thought it would be fun to do a satirical overview of Connecticut personal injury law. Join The Law Office of Christopher J. Mutchler, a Limited Liability Company over the course of the next twelve days to share a laugh and learn some tort law! Links to each portion of this twelve-part series will be provided below as they become available. Happy holidays!

Life’s not always fair, but it may be fairer than you think it is. If you’re in a bind, The Law Office of Christopher J. Mutchler may be able to help.

“Copyright Trolling” – How Connecticut Businesses Are Getting Burned For Streaming Music

You may have heard about restaurants and other small business in Connecticut being sued over playing music for their customers. It can be extremely damaging to a business, and it seems to be happening more and more. What’s going on?
Well, these types of actions tend to start off when a mass licensing agency sends one of its employees to a business location, and tells the employee to write down every song that is played while they are there. If someone had done this at your business, chances are good that you would never even have noticed them. The employee is typically instructed to act naturally, and to make full use of the establishment.  At a restaurant, the employee may sit down and eat; and at a store, he/she may actually shop (it sounds like a great job).
The employee then sends the list he made to his boss, who runs it through a computer and determines which of those titles the company owns a license to. If (or more likely, when – the registries are pretty extensive) there is a hit for a song that the licensing company has an interest in, legal action begins.
Generally, a cease and desist letter is sent to the business before anything gets taken further. Often times, this letter will include a settlement demand and a draft complaint of a complaint to be filed in Federal Court. These documents will typically allege a litany of Federal claims, most often involving copyright infringement (I call this practice “copyright trolling,” due to the similarities between it and patent trolling). While which particular law (if any) was violated depends heavily on the situation, the result is often the same.
If a business owner has not looked into the surrounding law (e.g., 17 U.S.C. § 110), the licensing company may have him or her “dead to rights.” Intellectual property law is astoundingly complex, and often requires oddly specific things (for instance, the number of speakers through which music is played may be the key to whether a business owner has to pay). Relatively few attorneys practice intellectual property law, and copyright is an area that is constantly changing to react to technology. Further, copyrights are governed by Federal law, and Federal Courts are notoriously slow, in part because of the complexity of their procedural rules (in contrast to those of State court).
The result of all this is that settlement is often times much cheaper than fighting. Between the complexity of governing law and the general practice of barring disclosure after settlement, many small business owners become aware of this problem after they have been sued.
So what can be done? Well, that depends on where you are in the process. If you are a business owner looking to avoid suit, contact an attorney for advice on how to avoid this and other common pitfalls. If you have received a cease and desist letter, take the letter seriously. Do not, under any circumstance, ignore it; doing so could result in increased damages. If you are unsure on how to proceed, contact an attorney.
Life’s not always fair, but it may be fairer than you think it is. If your business is in a bind, The Law Office of Christopher J. Mutchler may be able to help. Give us a call, shoot us a text, send us an email, or Contact Us.
By:    Christopher J. Mutchler, Esq.

What Is Injury Law?

“Injury Law” (or, more formally, “tort law”) is a collection of guidelines that are used to determine how society will respond to injuries inflicted upon one person by another. Put simply, when someone acts in a way that causes someone else to be injured, the law sometimes requires the injurer to pay money to his victim. This, of course, is distinct from any criminal charges that may arise as the result of the injurers actions.

Simple, right? Well, not always. If John Everyman down the road blows through a stop sign and slams into Little Susie on her bike, you don’t need to be a lawyer to know that John Everyman is probably going to be liable to Little Susie for her injuries. And generally speaking, this is correct. In all likelihood, what would happen here is that Little Susie’s mom would get on the phone with someone from John Everyman’s insurance company, and John Everyman’s insurance company would (eventually) agree pay for Little Susie’s treatment. Their offer might not be as much as Little Susie may be entitled to at law, but that’s another issue entirely.

But what about something a little more complicated? Take this hypothetical:

How about instead of your average neighbor down the street, Joe Blow is a classic car enthusiast. You know the type. He has a garage full of every tool imaginable, and every Sunday before the game he’s elbow deep in the hood of something different. He’s been working on a gorgeous 1967 in his garage for a few weeks, and has it almost ready-to-go. The neighborhood kids surround him, eager for a look up close. But because it’s not completely done, Joe hasn’t added it to his insurance policy yet. The premium on something like that costs a pretty penny, and so do its parts. Money doesn’t grow on trees, and that cost is better spent elsewhere.

One beautiful Connecticut summer afternoon, Joe Blow decides to take off from work an hour early and enjoy the weather. Somewhere along I-91 South, it occurs to Joe that it be really nice to go for a quick cruise around the block in his close-to-finished pride and joy. “Ya, it’s illegal,” he thinks, “but I’ll be fast. No one will know. No harm, no foul.” (On a side note, you should not do this. Driving without insurance in Connecticut is a crime.)

However, in an odd twist of legal fortune that would make any law school torts professor proud (they are known for writing the most obscure hypotheticals imaginable), it seems that everyone in Connecticut had the same idea as Joe. As soon as he nears Hartford, traffic comes to a dead crawl in typical Connecticut-rush-hour fashion. “Wonderful,” he sneers, “an accident.” After about an hour, traffic starts moving, and Joe is able to see what the excessive rubber-necking was all about (Joe heard on the radio that, thankfully, there were no serious injuries). “Oooooooh,” he moans to himself, “that looks just like my ‘76! I wouldn’t want to be that guy!” He continues on his way, and – as every Connecticut commuter has experienced – gets home around the same time he would have had he left work at the normal time.

When he opens his garage though, something is missing. Panicked, he looks quickly into his back yard, but sees nothing but some scraps of broken fence. He rushes inside to look for the keys. As he thrusts open the drawer he thought he put them in, his phone begins to ring. “Not now!!!” he screams at no one, and continues rummaging violently through his drawers. “AAAAAHHHGHH!!!” he yells, exasperatedly. He lower himself onto the kitchen floor, back against the refrigerator, and rests his head in his arms, defeated. Suddenly, he hears over the speaker of his home answering machine: “… the vehicle was totaled, and the suspects are in custody. Please give us a call when you get this, our number again is 555-555-5555. Thank you.”

Come to find out, some neighborhood kids broke into Joe’s garage and took his car for a joy ride. That traffic he was stuck in? You guessed it. Over the course of the next few months, everything is worked out with Joe’s insurance providers. For legal reasons far too complex to get into, the kids who stole Joe’s car turned out to be insolvent, so he couldn’t get any money from them, but he lawyered up and everything worked out.

Until one day Joe gets a demand letter in the mail from his neighbor, Ned Nabors. Those scraps of broken fence in the yard? Those were from Ned’s fence. It was destroyed in the theft, and Ned has been unable to get it paid for by the kids who did it. He’s demanded Joe pay for it. What happens here is not as obvious.

The answer, as always in law, is that it depends. As stupid as it sounds, there is a very real possibility that Ned may be able to recover from Joe, particularly if Joe was negligent (like if Joe left the keys inside of his convertible car which he stored with its top down under a tent outside). Complex problems like these are why injury lawyers can be helpful. Life’s not fair, but it may be fairer than you think it is. If you’ve been hurt or injured, M&M Legal LLC may be able to help. Give us a call, shoot us a text, or send us an email!

–    Christopher J. Mutchler, Esq.

* The above is provided as solely as a means of attorney advertising. Nothing contained herein should be taken to constitute legal advice, nor does it create an attorney client relationship. If you have a legal issue, it is important to contact and/or retain competent legal counsel.

WordPress Resources at SiteGround

WordPress is an award-winning web software, used by millions of webmasters worldwide for building their website or blog. SiteGround is proud to host this particular WordPress installation and provide users with multiple resources to facilitate the management of their WP websites:

Expert WordPress Hosting

SiteGround provides superior WordPress hosting focused on speed, security and customer service. We take care of WordPress sites security with unique server-level customizations, WP auto-updates, and daily backups. We make them faster by regularly upgrading our hardware, offering free CDN with Railgun and developing our SuperCacher that speeds sites up to 100 times! And last but not least, we provide real WordPress help 24/7! Learn more about SiteGround WordPress hosting

WordPress tutorial and knowledgebase articles

WordPress is considered an easy to work with software. Yet, if you are a beginner you might need some help, or you might be looking for tweaks that do not come naturally even to more advanced users. SiteGround WordPress tutorial includes installation and theme change instructions, management of WordPress plugins, manual upgrade and backup creation, and more. If you are looking for a more rare setup or modification, you may visit SiteGround Knowledgebase.

Free WordPress themes

SiteGround experts not only develop various solutions for WordPress sites, but also create unique designs that you could download for free. SiteGround WordPress themes are easy to customize for the particular use of the webmaster.